Ready-to-teach lesson
ELA SKILL LESSON · GRADE 1
The Dot
Analyze Sequence
TIME
PRIMARY SKILL
OBJECTIVE
STUDENT EVIDENCE
ESSENTIAL QUESTION
30 minutes full · 15 minutes short Infer how a character’s attitude changes from words and actions Compare Vashti’s actions and words near the beginning, middle, and end to explain how her attitude toward drawing changes.
Three moments in one attitude-change arc, each supported by an action or phrase.
How do Vashti’s actions show that her attitude toward drawing changes?
Before teaching
Read or play the complete book before the timed lesson. Mark the first mark, her response to the framed dot, and her response to the boy.
- Materials:
- The book; Student Evidence page; pencil.
Mark these moments: forceful first mark · reaction to the framed dot · response to the boy who says he cannot draw
Lesson sequence
- 4 min
- Beginning Reread the first-mark moment. Name what Vashti does or says before choosing a word for her attitude.
- 6 min
- Middle Compare her reaction to the framed dot. Ask what new action shows she is becoming willing to try or prove something.
- 10 min
- End Read her response to the boy. Notice that she now gives someone else a way to begin.
- 10 min
- Build the arc Put the three moments in order and explain the change using only the cited actions/words.
TumbleTA | ELA Skill Lesson | Grade 1 | The Dot Page 1 ELA SKILL LESSON · TEACHER
SUPPORT · GRADE 1
- The Dot
- Analyze Sequence
- Access routes
- SOLO
- Record beginning, middle, and end actions, then write one sentence explaining the attitude change.
- SUPPORTED
- Choose from a small word bank only after pointing to the action or phrase that supports each stage.
page 1
- LISTENING
- Replay one marked moment at a time. Give the action and what it suggests orally; an adult may scribe.
- EXTEND
- Explain which moment is the clearest turning point and why, using evidence.
Teacher guidance
Keep all three moments serving one target: attitude change. Do not split the lesson into separate mood-inference and “what she says to the boy” tasks. The boy scene is evidence of the completed change.
Assessment
- Uses an action/phrase from the first mark.
- Uses an action/phrase from the framed-dot response.
- Uses Vashti’s response to the boy as end-of-arc evidence.
- Explains a plausible change in attitude across the three moments.
Short route · 15 minutes 3 min - first mark. 5 min - framed-dot response. 7 min - boy scene and one-sentence change explanation.
TumbleTA | ELA Skill Lesson | Grade 1 | The Dot Page 2
STUDENT EVIDENCE · GRADE 1
The Dot
How Vashti Changes
Name ______________________________________ Date __________________ Use one action or phrase from each moment. Then explain how Vashti’s attitude toward drawing changes across the story.
BEGINNING
What does Vashti do or say? What does that suggest?
MIDDLE
What does she do after seeing the framed dot? What does that suggest?
END
What does she do when the boy says he cannot draw? What does that show now?
EXIT CHECK
Vashti’s attitude changes from __________________ to __________________ because __________________.
TumbleTA | ELA Skill Lesson | Grade 1 | The Dot Page 3
page 2
TEACHER KEY · GRADE 1
The Dot
Analyze Sequence
Strong response
At the beginning, Vashti acts abruptly and resists drawing. After seeing the framed dot, she reacts by deciding she can do better and begins making more dots. At the end, when the boy says he cannot draw, she gives him a way to begin. Together, those actions support a change from resistance/frustration toward engagement and confidence that drawing can start with a small mark.
Expected evidence
- Beginning: forceful mark / short reply shows resistance or frustration.
- Middle: decides she can do better and acts on it.
- End: helps the boy begin instead of dismissing him.
Watch for
- Treating each scene as an unrelated mood-label exercise.
- Using “happy” without evidence.
- Inventing the teacher’s private intention.
Independent success
The student uses evidence from all three moments to explain one coherent change in Vashti’s attitude.
TumbleTA | ELA Skill Lesson | Grade 1 | The Dot Page 4
page 3